SCO Summit: Complex Geopolitics of the Broad Space

13.06.2017

With the formal accession of India and Pakistan, the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) has extended its list of full members beyond the borders of Central Asia. So what sort of organization does that make it? It’s an appropriate time to take stock given the recent SCO summit which concluded on 9 June.

The SCO is notable for including security cooperation and anti-terrorism among its objectives, but it does not intend to be a military bloc, and the Collective Security Treaty Organization is supposed to serve that function in Central Asia in any case. Members talk often about economics, but the role of two outside projects — China’s Belt and Road and the Eurasian Economic Union —dwarfs that of the SCO itself as the primary government platforms for discussions on trade and investment. The organization certainly brings its members under one roof and encourages dialogue, but it cannot hope to solve the bitter territorial and political disputes between India and Pakistan. Not even Belt and Road is a unifying factor. India resists the program, skeptical that it will significantly expand Chinese influence in the region. Prime Minister Narendra Modi said as much during his address in Astana, implying that Belt and Road can pose a threat to national sovereignty. 

What can be said of the SCO is that it reflects the complex geopolitics of the broad space its members now represent. India wants to expand its trade ties in Central Asia and with Russia, and entering the organization alongside Pakistan may well be intended to check both Pakistan and a growing Chinese presence. For Russia and China, the organization can more strongly claim to represent a non-Western pole, fuzzy though its contours may be. And for Central Asia, it never hurts to bring rival suitors for investment and trade ties closer together. 

clipboard01.jpg

Infographics: India and Pakistan Join the SCO

More concretely, at the summit the SCO deepened its commitment to combatting terrorism, and continued discussions of an SCO development bank. Both initiatives have potential. Perhaps the SCO powers could extend the reach of the anti-terrorism efforts by seeking cooperation on the issue with the broader international community. A global effort is needed, and the sphere is one where the SCO can make a key contribution. 

Views expressed are of individual Members and Contributors, rather than the Club's, unless explicitly stated otherwise.

Related articles

Ulf Sverdrup on the European Union's New Foreign Policy Issues
20.10.2017
Ulf Sverdrup, Director of the Norwegian Institute of International Affairs (NUPI), talks about the consequences of Brexit for the European Union and new dynamics in the EU's relations with

Category:
Video
Why Shinzo Abe Needs Early Elections?
20.10.2017
Abe announced the elections in order to preserve the majority, which guarantees his premiership for a third term, and apparently, he keeps bargaining chip. He caught his opponents by surprise, whom he

Expert: 
Andrey Fesyun

Category:
Expert Opinions
Day 4 of the Valdai Club 14th Annual Meeting
20.10.2017
The most highly anticipated event of the last day of the XIV Annual meeting of the Valdai Club was undoubtedly the meeting with the President of the Russian Federation Vladimir Putin. The traditional

Category:
Video