Despite Grave Times, Merkel May Still Come Out on Top


History is full of bad outcomes and there is nothing that signals that a good outcome is guaranteed after Angela Merkel’s CDU-CSU bloc failed to form a government in Germany, Michael Stürmer, Chief Correspondent at WELT-Gruppe in Berlin told However, according to Stürmer, Merkel will survive this storm and can assume control of the situation.

Angela Merkel has already announced that she is in favour of a new election after coalition talks collapsed this week. Do you think it will take place?

All options are available. Early election is the worst one, because it will prolong the limbo in which Germany presently finds itself. There is no reason to believe that the result will be really different. It looks like a way out of the crisis but it is not. It’s an illusion. I think that the current government and the president will do their utmost to revise the present state of affairs.

Is Angela Merkel’s political future at risk?

Of course, it is at risk. In a parliamentary democracy, political life of leaders is always at risk, at present a little bit more than usual. There are voices who believe that she is responsible for the rise of AfD, which, together with Die Linke, is blocking the normal way of arranging a government. But this is also very vague. However, I believe that she will manage, she is best when she is with her back against the wall, and this is the present situation.

How did Free Democrats become the main spoiler?

It is difficult to say. My feeling is that it unsettled them, but they should have swallowed more of the things they hate. Because what they will get now will be a lot of doubt. They were out of parliament until the recent election. Basically, they have no organization, they are a kind of floating power and they operate on a very high risk. The 5 percent minimum close is always with them. Although now they crossed ten percent of the vote, that vote is not very stable. And, given the key role of the Free Democrats in the crisis, that may turn out to be the beginning of the end for the liberals. The liberals are always balancing on the edge of the abyss.

Is any agreement with SPD possible?

What you have seen so far is the knee-jerk rejection on the part of the present chairman of the Social Democrats Martin Schulz, who wants to preserve his leadership role. In a grand coalition, he would have to serve under Angela Merkel, whom he hates. But others, like the current foreign minister [Sigmar Gabriel], wouldn’t mind. So, Social Democrats are pretty much divided. The façade is one of unity, and this is what it should be, but behind the façade, they are very much divided.

Is a grand coalition possible?

It is, but there is a 10 percent chance, no more. You have the option of minority government, you have the option of new elections. Social democrats hate it when they have to move, but they are a party which loves to be in opposition. At the same time, they are a party with a lot of willingness to carry high political responsibility. That they have always shown, in good times and in bad times. In no way is this the last word on what is going to happen in three or four weeks’ time. We are in the middle of a moving drama.

Will the domestic situation become aggravated if the AfD gets more votes?

That would teach all parliamentary parties a very serious lesson. That’s the good side and the bad side is that it narrows the field of manoeuvre for other parties. This could happen – and this is a very bad outcome. But history is full of bad outcomes, why not this time? 

Views expressed are of individual Members and Contributors, rather than the Club's, unless explicitly stated otherwise.

Related articles

Trump’s Move on Iran Deal Raises Prominence of Putin-Merkel Meeting
Donald Trump’s reckless policy vis-à-vis Iran has substantially changed the originally not very promising agenda of the Putin-Merkel meeting in Sochi on May 18, Hans-Joachim Spanger writes.

Expert Opinions
Progress of Nord Stream 2 and Its Role for Russian Gas Exports to the EU
Opponents trying to prevent Nord Stream2, especially from Poland, often claim that the project has no economic rationale and it is mainly a politically motivated project; they try to portray Ukrainian

Ralf Dickel

Expert Opinions
Nord Stream 2: Catch-22 for Germany
Cancelling Nord Stream 2 would be a colossal blow to Russian-German cooperation in energy supplies and to German credibility in any future negotiations with Russia, both on the state and the business

Expert Opinions


Popular tags


Type your E-mail to subscribe to Valdai Club newsletter